Charlize Theron was on Jimmy Kimmel Live this week, and in the course of their conversation Kimmel mentioned that the last time Theron visited his stage, President Barack Obama was also on the show. That led Theron to describe her very nervous first meeting with the president, and the very awkward moment that followed. Obama told her that he was interested in doing shows like Kimmel’s because it allowed him to reach a demographic he might not otherwise get to address, to which Theron replied “Well, if you’re looking for a different demographic, I can take you to a strip club.”

It’s probably not the weirdest thing someone’s ever said to Obama, but Theron probably at least made the top 10, and the moment is capped off by Kimmel realizing that he has the perfect opportunity to nail a Bill Clinton joke.