In the age of Facebook and Instagram, it’s hard to get away with anything—especially cheating, if you’re dumb enough to allow photographic evidence. One English guy learned that lesson the hard way this week, after a photo of him making out with a random girl named Pippa at a club made its way back to people who recognized him.

He apparently made quite the impression on Pippa, who wanted to see him again after their encounter:

At first, Pippa’s friends share the post eagerly, thinking it’s kind of Facebook-age romantic:

But then, someone on Facebook—who is friends with they guy’s girlfriend—tags her in a comment:

And then, as these things happen, the truth came out: