Magic Mike XXL hit theaters this week, to the delight of women (and, let’s be honest, more than a few men) across America. Conan O'Brien took notice of the number of women working on his staff who couldn’t wait to see the film, and decided to turn their girls’ night out into a segment on his show. He didn’t use the segment to mock the Magic Mike XXL experience, though. Instead, he wanted to find out which of the film’s stars women like best, hear their theories on penis size, and test his own Magic Mike-ish dance moves. By the end, he seems like a convert, and not just because of the bedroom cameo that closes the bit.