A good rule of thumb you learn as a child is to proceed with caution, because things aren’t always as they appear. If a strange man invites you into his car for some candy, he probably doesn’t have any candy. Your neighbor’s dog may look really friendly, but that doesn’t mean he won’t bite you.

This adage also applies to shady strip joints you encounter on family road trips through what seems like the middle of nowhere, but is really just upstate New York. If you pass by a place called the Banana Creamery, you shouldn’t count on them serving diner food—and the daily special is definitely not a milkshake.

See how it unfolds in this scene from The Detour, premiering Monday, April 11th at 9/8c with back-to-back episodes on TBS.