Despite Friends ending over 10 years ago, it still holds a special place in our hearts, especially for those of us who grew up with the show. And even though we can now watch the iconic show on Netflix, fans of the show were completely gutted when it ended.

The ending, which many fans thought was perfect, depicted the six characters leaving Monica’s apartment to head into their new lives. Despite the fairy tale ending, one fan shared their opinion on how the show should have really ended, featuring everyone’s favorite quirky character, Phoebe. However, fans were less than pleased and absolutely freaked out over this new, dark fan theory.

Warning, you might not like what you’re about to read: