Kylie Jenner’s latest Instagram pics are attracting more attention than usual. Not only is she topless in the black-and-white images shot by photographer Sasha Samsonova, she’s smoking. It’s unclear if that’s a hand-rolled cigarette or a join in her hand, but the photos have sparked debate among her 87.7 million followers.

🖤

A post shared by Kylie (@kyliejenner) on

The 19-year-old reality TV star and entrepreneur is fully made up in the photos, and the fact that she’s smoking seems intended to add to the glamor. While some followers applaud her for holding what they believe to be a joint, others are criticizing her for lighting up at all, since she has many young fans who consider her a role model.

With my 🖤 @kyliejenner 📷🎞

A post shared by Sasha Samsonova (@sashasamsonova) on

Jenner poses for Samsonova on a regular basis, and this isn’t the first time she has smoked on camera during one of their shoots. Jenner also lights a cigarette at the beginning of the steamy video she posted in late 2016 as a holiday gift for her fans. That, too, was directed by Samsonova. As far as we know, Jenner doesn’t smoke in “real life,” so all this smoking raises a few questions: Does she only smoke when she and Samsonova are together? Does Samsonova just like taking pictures of smoke as it swirls through the air?

Either way, on behalf of all the fans who track Jenner’s every move, we hope it’s a short-term habit. Seriously, Kylie—smoking makes people look old and wrinkly, and then it kills them. We want you to live a long, healthy life, during which you share billions of gorgeous selfies with the world.