Late Late Show host James Corden just keeps upping the silliness factor when it comes to games he plays with guests. Last night he invited actor and American Hero Nick Offerman, along with Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt star Ellie Kemper and Silicon Valley star Thomas Middleditch, to play a game of “Nuzzle Waaa?” in which two contestants were blindfolded and then asked to guess what object they’d just shoved their face into.

As is usually the case with late night games like this, things started simple, then Kemper basically made out with a giant gummy bear, and Offerman and Corden got to know a live snake very well.