We cannot ship your order until you add a shipping address. Click Here

Sorry, Men: Women Still Want You to Pay on Dates

A new Seeking campaign starring Julia Fox suggests women should reject going Dutch. I asked women what they really think about men picking up the tab.

Sex & Relationships • November 19, 2026
Sorry, Men: Women Still Want You to Pay on Dates

Who pays for the first date? You’d think we’d have a more straightforward answer to that question these days. When asked, many will give a polite, concise answer: whoever initiated the date should pay the bill. 

But among straight daters, just about everyone knows this is code. Despite decades of effort toward gender equity—and the fact that women are now more likely to out-earn men in certain cities—the real answer is still the man.

“If a man doesn’t pay on a date, I assume he just wants to be friends,” Ashley, 31, tells me. 

Last week, I polled women on Instagram about their expectations around splitting the bill on a date. Dozens of women responded saying specifically that if a man asks them out, they expect him him to be the one to pay the bill. At the same time, though, most of the dates they go on are initiated by the man to begin with. Even so, there’s nuance here. 

Between the labor women put into their looks, the cost of makeup, and the risk of bodily harm (I could go on!), there are still countless ways in which dating is not an entirely equitable experience between men and women. As many women noted, in terms of both time and money, getting ready for a date is expensive. By that measure, it’s only fair for the guy to cover the cost of dinner. “They pay, period,” says Kennedy, 26. “The cost of my skincare, makeup, outfit, hair, car home…the salmon sperm microneedling… that’s $375!” 

On November 10th, “success-minded” dating site Seeking—formerly known as Seeking Arrangement—launched a new Anti-50/50 campaign starring Julia Fox, paired with a study conducted by the platform. In the campaign video, Julia Fox serves as a sort of Ghost of Christmas Past, Present and Future, warning women of the future of romantic disappointment that will befall them should they agree to split the bill on a first date. On Seeking, the campaign implies, women can meet men for whom going Dutch isn’t on the table. In the company’s survey of 1,063 heterosexual adults, a quarter of women said being asked to split the bill was a deal-breaker. 

“When Seeking launched in 2006, it was built around accomplished men who…weren’t necessarily finding compatible partners on mainstream dating platforms,” says Dana Rosewall, co-CEO of Seeking. To put it into plain terms, it was often used by younger women looking for financially well-off men who were willing to spoil them, and by financially well-off men looking for the company of an attractive younger woman. A tale as old as time, but one rarely spoken aloud, nevermind made accessible through a dating site (though, it’s worth noting that Seeking explicitly forbids sugar daddy dynamics and transactional relationships). 

“Twenty years later, that fundamental dynamic hasn’t changed, but the people on both sides have evolved,” says Rosewall. She notes that massive growth in tech, crypto and AI has made a younger crop of eligible bachelors extremely wealthy, dropping the average age of men on the site from 47 to 42. Meanwhile, the average age of female members sits at around 26. 

“But perhaps the biggest evolution we’ve seen is in their confidence and independence,” says Rosewall. “They’re increasingly comfortable defining the relationship dynamics they actually want. That’s especially evident among younger women, who are challenging the idea that gender equality must mean splitting everything down the middle.”

Many of the women I spoke to put their preference for being paid for in similar terms. “My expectation — and what seems to be a shared expectation amongst other women in their late 20s that identify as feminist and could technically pay for a meal ourselves — is that we do indeed want to be paid for,” says Kayleigh, 27. “I think there was a time in my younger and mid-20s where I wanted to prove my ‘feminism,’ my independence and my desire to decenter gendered expectations by paying and splitting date costs. But ultimately, that built resentment.”

Now, Kayleigh says, she embraces the dynamic. “It feels almost wrong to be treated financially…and that in itself is quite hot,” she says. In fact, she goes so far as to label it a kink. “Reframing being paid for as a kink or a turn-on, as opposed to an obligation or gendered expectation is where the spark is.”

What’s most interesting to me about the Seeking campaign and the continued discourse around first-date spending is that it is specifically targeting young women. The messaging isn’t that men should be more generous, but that women shouldn’t be willing to accept less from men. What if instead of yielding happier dynamics around the financials of dating, we are shifting expectations to be even more antagonistic?

For a platform like Seeking, that isn’t exactly an issue—it’s a dating site that is rather clear in its premise that in straight couples, the man will pay. Its dynamics don’t exactly mirror those of other dating apps. In fact, Seeking is one of the only dating sites where women outnumber men, at a rate of four to one, and women tend to send the first message, co-CEO Brandon Wade notes. 

It’s worth noting that while many women do expect, or at least prefer, for a man to cover the costs of the first date, it isn’t necessarily an expectation they hold in perpetuity. “On the first date, I would hope he pays, especially if he’s the one who asks me out,” says Mia, 26. “I do always offer to split, and if he takes me up on it, it wouldn’t be a dealbreaker. If I’m consistently dating someone I think it’s nice to switch off who pays.”

In many ways, the continued insistence on men paying for the first date is just a matter of social norms and politeness. We want men to pay because it’s what we’ve come to expect from the rules of chivalry and courtship, even if there are plenty of feminist arguments against those, too. Yes, yes, we’re twenty-first century independent women, but when a man adheres to this one cultural practice of treating us well, it’s a decent sign he’ll do the same in other ways in the future. Not a guarantee, to be sure, but a sign. 

“The modern empowered woman doesn’t need a man to pay for dinner,” says Rosewall. “She wants a man who wants to.” The challenge, then, isn’t necessarily in convincing more women to expect men to pay—it’s in helping more men feel up to the task.

More From Playboy

Your Bag

Your bag is empty.