The NFL has a knack for scripting stories that defy logic, and Week 17’s primetime showdown between the Chicago Bears and San Francisco 49ers was no exception.
In case you missed the game during the holidays, here’s a recap. Week 17 Sunday Night Football fans witnessed a thrilling 42-38 victory for the 49ers at Levi’s Stadium. San Francisco kept its hopes alive for the NFC’s top seed, but the win also highlighted one of football’s greatest ironies.
At the center of it all were two QBs whose draft stories couldn’t be more contrasting: Caleb Williams, the Bears’ highly touted No. 1 overall pick from the 2024 draft, and Brock Purdy, the very last selection of the 2022 draft, famously dubbed “Mr. Irrelevant.”
What unfolded was a back-and-forth shootout where Purdy’s poise and playmaking ultimately overshadowed Williams’ flashy arm talent, reminding everyone that draft position is no guarantee of success. While Williams represents the pinnacle of scouting hype, Purdy embodies the hidden potential lurking in the draft’s depths.
Brock Purdy Shines at Home vs Bears
Purdy’s journey from the 262nd pick in the 2022 NFL Draft to a primetime hero is the stuff of football folklore. Nicknamed “Mr. Irrelevant” for being the final selection, Purdy stepped into the spotlight during his rookie year when injuries thrust him into the starting role.
In that game, Purdy demonstrated why he’s become indispensable to the 49ers’ high-powered offense. He overcame an early interception to lead a 65-yard TD on the next drive that tied the game.
What set Purdy apart on Sunday night was his dual-threat capability. In addition to throwing for 303 passing yards and three TDs through the air, he added 28 rushing yards and two scores on the ground, becoming only the sixth player since the AFL-NFL merger to record back-to-back games with at least five total TDs.
Purdy’s 118.6 passer rating reflected near-flawless execution for most of the night, including a fourth-quarter 38-yard TD strike to Jauan Jennings that gave the 49ers a 42-38 lead with 2:15 remaining. Purdy’s offense racked up 496 total yards, exploiting the Bears’ defense in a way that highlighted his growth into a savvy, mobile QB.
His performance included a highlight-reel TD pass that lasted over eight seconds, evading rushers before flipping the ball to fullback Kyle Juszczyk.
Critics once questioned Purdy’s arm strength and pedigree, but performances like this silence the doubters. His ability to extend plays, as seen in that eight-second scramble TD, showcases a maturity beyond his years.
Caleb Williams Comes Up Short vs 49ers
For Williams, the 2024 No. 1 overall pick, the night’s loss was a tough pill to swallow, but it didn’t come without silver linings. The second-year QB has already etched his name in the record books with six comebacks after trailing in the final two minutes of regulation – an NFL record.
Against the 49ers, he threw for 330 yards on 25-of-42 attempts, with two TDs, earning a solid 100.3 passer rating. The Bears’ offense totaled 440 yards, boosted by RB D’Andre Swift’s 54 yards and two TDs, and WR Luther Burden III’s 138 receiving yards and TD. Yet, the game’s decisive moment came on the final drive, where pressure from 49ers EDGE Bryce Huff forced an errant throw, sealing Chicago’s fate.
Despite the defeat, Williams’ performance underscores his potential as the Bears’ franchise savior. He’s transformed a once-struggling offense into a playoff contender, and while he couldn’t outpace Purdy this time, the experience will only fuel his development.
The Bears had a chance to win the game in the closing seconds but couldn’t make the big play when it mattered most.
Playoff Ramifications for 49ers & Bears
The 49ers’ win propels them to 12-4, keeping their NFC top-seed dreams alive with a Week 18 matchup against Seattle. A victory there could secure home-field advantage, a boon for a team that’s won six straight and boasts a balanced attack.
For the Bears, dropping to 11-5 ends their top-seed aspirations, but as NFC North champs, they will host a wild-card game. This loss exposes defensive vulnerabilities, as they allowed nearly 500 total yards, but their offensive firepower suggests they’re built for a lasting postseason run.
Beyond the standings, this game teaches enduring lessons about the NFL Draft. Purdy’s success challenges the notion that early picks guarantee stardom, while Williams’ solid outing amid defeat shows that even elite talents need time to mature.
In an era of QB-driven narratives, this clash reminds us that heart, scheme, and opportunity often trump hype. As both teams gear up for January, the league watches to see if Purdy can lead another deep run or if Williams sparks a Bears’ resurgence.