This is The Manthropologist, a column by Charlie Sosnick about the Internet and the male mind.
This past weekend, I was stranded in the Dominican Republic for three days due to ripple effects of the ground stop from the Federal Aviation Administration. When my first flight was cancelled, every remaining option disappeared after they were added to my cart, as if the airline’s online booking system had been cleverly designed to taunt me. I considered calling the airline, but I knew it would be useless. I have no airline elite status, no premium credit cards, and no great hoard of points or excess cash lying around for upgrades. I chose to spare myself the humiliation since I occupy the lowest position on the air-travel totem pole: Peon.
Air travel is the rare zone of life in which status plays out totally publicly. Line-cutting upgrades like TSA PreCheck and CLEAR have turned security into a timed race. Lounges serve you free buffets in comfortable chairs while commoners pay $21 for an hours-old turkey sandwich. The boarding process sorts you into as many as nine tiers of priority. Those at the bottom of the zone-caste system will face the further indignity of gate-checking their bag. On the plane itself, the highest classes will clink champagne flutes and lay in cozy beds, while the teeming masses bump elbows and eat Goldfish in plane steerage.
However you feel about your class position or financial situation, the airport will present you with someone doing better. Are you strong enough to accept it? Or will you go to great lengths to keep up appearances?
Airport status anxiety is a male-dominated field. According to a 2019 U.S. News survey, men are more likely to have a travel credit card and more likely to use the points on flight upgrades. Men are more likely than women to spend their credit card rewards on travel, and less likely than women to get cash back. Within the airline industry, men are also known for hoarding their points for years on end for some imagined future splurge. In Barclays studies, men prioritized earning rewards over getting the best price, and preferred “exclusivity-focused rewards” such as upgrades and lounge access over “comfort” perks like more legroom.
For men, the airport is a battleground of intrasexual competition, the biological mechanism by which men attempt to establish social hierarchies. This is why men spend so much time, money, and effort on something as trivial as Delta Medallion levels. This is not logical, per se, but neither is attempting to drive faster than the car in the next lane or getting a new pool to one-up your neighbor. Yet we still do it. Males of all species expend resources to signal strength and power, whether it be a moose fighting with their antlers or a guy spending $795 a year on Chase Sapphire Reserve.
I first began to notice my friends becoming fixated on air travel about a decade ago in my early 20s. Out of nowhere, my peers began dropping tiny flexes about trips paid for with sign-up bonuses, and complaints about work travel became thinly-veiled humblebrags about airline status. In college, these topics would be too boring and lame to care about, let alone discuss publicly. But in the early days of adulthood, when everyone is still mostly broke, sharing apartments, and eating leftovers, credit cards and airline miles can serve as the first social signals of upward mobility and the spoils of corporate life. Once, I was meeting a friend who works in finance at the airport before a group vacation. After a friend of mine in finance barely made it to the gate for a group vacation, he drunkenly confessed that he had been in the Amex lounge the entire time – and had kept it a secret so as not to embarrass me.
All of these upgrades imply wealth, or at least income. The airlines and credit-card companies have worked hard to make it that way, but they are not necessarily the result of having more money. It can all be gamed. Boarding zones and upgrades are gained by flying more frequently and loyally, usually because you have to do it for work. Lounge access and TSA PreCheck requires a relatively manageable annual expense of under $1,000, which is why they’re both so crowded now. Hopping on a flight is no longer a luxury good – and everyone on the flight, no matter where they’re sitting, is in the same permanent underclass of people that are still flying commercial.
To cope, men continually reinforce the value of these experiences, constantly reminding us that this stupid game is worth playing. In the end, I paid $400 to fly home at 7 a.m. on Tuesday in economy. I took my shoes off in security, ate a terrible and expensive sandwich in the concourse, and boarded in Zone 4. I’d like to say I don’t play the status game, but it’s not possible to opt out. Instead, I am simply humble in defeat.
